Hg Release from Amalgams Actually Measured!

Summary: Mercury emissions from single-spill samples of three popular precapsulated amalgams, Tytin, Dispersalloy, and Valiant, were measured in water at room temperature, 23o C. Daily emission was 4.5 to 21 micrograms per day, much higher than previously “estimated” values offered by ADA spokespeople in the past. It is now obvious why pro-amalgamists never actually measured these values.

A STUDY ON THE RELEASE OF MERCURY FROM DENTAL AMALGAMS MADE FROM DIFFERENT MANUFACTURED MATERIALS AND PRODUCED BY NINE DIFFERENT DENTISTS.

3 May 2007

This study was initiated in collaboration with the IAOMT to determine the amount of mercury released into distilled water at room temperature by dental amalgams made in Plexiglas molds drilled out to hold a single spill of amalgam. Nine such molds were sent to dentists along with unopened kits from the manufacturers. The amalgams were placed in the molds by these trained dentists and then sent to the Department of Chemistry at the University of Kentucky. At this location, the amalgams were removed from the molds and allowed to set for 3 months to insure total aging and the loss of surface bound mercury.

The amalgams were weighed and measured to determine surface area. They were then placed in 15 ml tubes with 10 ml of distilled water. The water was changed daily for a week and disposed of. At day one of the study, which lasted 28 days, the water was collected and the mercury was measured using a Nippon mercury vapor analyzer. Each day a standard curve was ran to insure the instrument was working properly.

The standard curve shows that the instrument can detect mercury in the low nanogram levels and the amount found in the test solutions were 1,000 times higher.

The following graph shows the data collected from three amalgams from each of the nine sets over a 28 day period. The values are microgams/cm2 surface area.

DENTISTS BRAND DAY1 DAY4 DAY8 DAY11 DAY15 DAY18 DAY22 DAY25
 #1 Tytin 14.207 13.175 12.244 11.835 11.639 11.568 14.147 13.240
    21.055 20.484 19.769 20.150 22.512 20.912 18.798 16.579
    9.407 8.281 8.693 9.731 9.556 11.781 9.799 9.219
#2 Tytin 9.024 8.662 8.272 7.521 8.043 11.216 9.515 8.670
    10.757 10.341 9.713 6.384 7.030 7.540 7.428 6.782
    7.539 7.108 6.656 6.508 6.899 6.508 6.959 8.200
#3 Dispersalloy 11.424 10.897 12.077 10.392 10.738 10.976 12.094 11.538
    8.242 7.675 8.123 7.425 7.499 8.872 8.588 8.463
    10.529 10.427 10.553 11.149 10.463 10.156 10.559 10.228
#4 Tytin 9.098 8.063 7.795 7.366 7.994 7.304 9.803 9.305
    10.949 10.216 10.773 10.431 12.250 11.319 12.476 11.197
    15.925 15.525 14.992 12.234 12.797 14.670 14.038 13.647

 

DENTISTS BRAND DAY1 DAY4 DAY8 DAY11 DAY15 DAY18 DAY22 DAY25
#5 Valiant 9.921 9.677 9.580 9.463 8.700 8.873 9.392 9.311
    9.751 9.262 8.886 8.202 8.074 8.014 9.563 10.322
    8.075 7.288 7.054 7.288 7.558 7.311 7.315 6.956
#6 Dispersalloy 9.966 9.620 10.851 10.590 11.260 9.070 9.280 9.014
    7.322 7.922 9.913 9.279 8.639 6.809 7.542 8.672
    9.206 8.685 8.599 8.480 7.783 8.270 7.936 8.997
#7 Valiant 5.958 5.829 4.408 4.533 4.266 4.473 5.136 4.460
    5.280 4.762 4.492 4.279 4.801 4.505 4.300 4.862
    4.596 4.704 4.929 4.867 6.147 5.798 5.936 5.468
#8 Valiant 6.841 6.904 6.788 5.782 8.158 7.740 7.893 8.026
    12.458 11.878 11.771 12.404 12.146 10.693 10.484 10.221
    13.911 13.421 12.618 11.176 11.669 13.439 13.208 13.090
#9 Dispersalloy 11.357 11.238 11.887 12.086 15.335 14.712 14.473 15.859
    17.796 17.484 16.765 19.584 19.321 20.716 20.696 19.995
    15.336 14.602 14.086 18.625 17.759 12.389 16.285 15.580

The table above is an abbreviated presentation of the results done to make the results more clear and presentable.  It should also be noted that the level of mercury emission was not stimulated by any brushing or manipulation of the amalgam.  Our previous studies showed that mild brushing with a standard toothbrush for just a few strokes will greatly increase the amount of mercury released, many times by over 10-fold.  Also, the reported measured mercury does not contain any “amalgam particles” that would be produced by brushing or abrasion. Great care was taken not to move the amalgam during the recovery of sampled water.  All 10 mls of the water were gently removed to insure proper mixing.  This is because we did an experiment removing the water 1 ml at a time from the top using a microliter pipette and noticed that the closer to the amalgam the higher the mercury concentration became.  Also, the surface area of all of the amalgams were very close in value with most being between 0.8 to 1.0 cm2 making the amount emitted per cm2 near the amount emitted per single spill filling.  The weight of the amalgams varied and averaged 0.663 g/amalgam and had a radius of 0.203 cm.  This would be the size of a small filling in the mouth.

While the amount of mercury released remained somewhat consistent within each amalgam it seems as if amalgam made by the same dentist on the same day could have a significant variability of mercury release even if from the same manufacturer.  Additionally, amalgam from the same manufacturer could produce significantly different levels of mercury release when prepared by different dentists, and sometimes even by the same dentist.  We do not know if this difference is due to the dentist’s technique or to a variation in the amalgam making materials.

Finally, even with the lowest level, 4 to 5 micrograms of mercury released per cm2, the level is considerably higher than that “estimated” by pro-amalgam supporters who testified before Congressional committees that the average amalgam released 0.03 micrograms Hg per day.  This is about 133 to 667 times higher than the estimated 0.03.  These values were obtained with the amalgams in a sealed container under 10 ml of water at room temperature of 23oC with no agitation or abrasion.  Therefore, these values must therefore be considered the minimum amount of mercury that could be emitted from these small amalgams.

Assuming the amalgams are 50% mercury and the emission of 5 micrograms Hg/day then it would take 182 years to lose all of the mercury if the rate stayed consistent.  At 20 micrograms per day the time would be 45 years.  Considering that 80% of inhaled mercury is retained in the human body for some extended period of time it is obvious that dental amalgams would be one of the major contributors to human mercury body burden.

Submitted by:  Dr. Boyd Haley
Professor of Chemistry and Biochemistry
University of Kentucky
Lexington, KY

2017-01-12T14:50:56+00:00